Nothing lasts forever…every tide has its ebb…all good things must come to an end…what goes around comes around…the bigger they are, the harder they fall.
My grandmother
What Just Happened
The simple explanation for the Blue Wave is depicted in the table below. Democrats reversed what Republicans did in 2024, when Republicans and Republican-leaning voters made up 49% of the electorate and gave the GOP 92% of their vote. In 2026, Democrats and Democratic-leaning voters made up 50% of the electorate and gave Democrats 98% of their vote (source: Fox News exit polling).
| PARTISAN BREAKDOWN OF ELECTION | |||
| Voting Bloc | 2024 | 2026 | Change |
| Dems/Leans Democrat | 44% | 50% | + 6 |
| GOP/Leans Republican | 49% | 43% | – 6 |
Right now, Democrats want 2028 to get here tomorrow. That’s what 256 House seats, 56 Senate seats, and 28 governors’ mansions do to politicians (source: NBC News). I have yet to hear a Democratic leader claim anything other than this bifurcated spin: the midterms are a rejection of President Trump and a mandate for our ideas. Not so fast—because for 200 years, presidents have watched their party lose seats in 44 of 48 midterms (92%), which means the out-party is supposed to win.
Before disparaging the President, Dems should remember that 64% of midterm-losing presidents went on to win their re-election bids, starting with Thomas Jefferson. In fact, the results could just as easily be a quirk of the modern two-party system because, since 2008, elections have become dramatically more cyclical and competitive than in any other era in American history (source: Pew Research).
What we’ve observed over the last 20 years is what political scientists call “thermostatic backlash.” That is, when one party wins a trifecta (like Democrats in 2008 and 2020, and Republicans in 2016 and 2024) and governs from its ideological base, swing voters quickly view the in-party as overreaching and turn the political thermostat back the other way in two years.
What Comes Next?
What should give Democrats pause is how Americans self-describe their political leanings: 35% conservative, 33% moderate, and only 28% liberal (source: Gallup 2026). Real question: how could voters in Kansas, North Carolina, and Ohio adopt election-integrity laws, AND send Democrats Adam Hamilton (KS), Roy Cooper (NC), and Sherrod Brown (OH) to the Senate?
Democrats need an answer, and they need it fast because they promised voters lower consumer prices and healthcare costs. Easier said than done with must-pass fiscal deadlines and Trump’s veto power awaiting. Their best-case scenario is moderation and small legislative wins, like consumer-protection legislation, making Medicare’s telehealth rules permanent, and expanding access to virtual healthcare.
So, with 2028 in mind, what Democrats do, say, and nominate matters more than historical footnotes. Already, Senate majority-leader wannabe Chris Van Hollen just promised to eliminate the filibuster, and AOC has signaled her intent to run for president in 2028. And so it begins—with two big hurdles ahead of them.
The first is the popularity of election-integrity laws. In February, 85% of registered voters said “only U.S. citizens should be allowed to vote,” and 75% said “voters should provide proof of citizenship” (source: Harvard CAPS/Harris). Meanwhile, 84% of U.S. adults support laws requiring all voters to show a valid photo ID to vote (source: Gallup).
When 82% of registered Democrats support citizens-only voting and 67% support states requiring a valid photo ID to vote – numbers that have held steady for years – how is it even possible that twenty-one Democrat governors and two Democrat attorneys general sued to block an executive order that would catch and prevent mail-in voter fraud?
Order 14399 requires every state sending or receiving federal mail-in ballots to follow Postal Service guidelines for envelopes, barcoding, and data reporting; thereby allowing USPS to track ballot envelopes and recipients, check eligibility against federal citizenship data, and catch fraudsters. I can think of only one reason to oppose the order, and that’s to make it easier to cheat by mail. If Democrats die on this hill, good riddance.
The second big hurdle is Life After Trump. Dems love that Trump’s personality is unmatched in generating record anti-incumbent turnout: the second-most midterm ballots ever cast in 2018, giving Dems the House, the most presidential ballots ever cast in 2020, putting Biden in the Oval Office, and the most midterm ballots ever cast in 2026, giving Dems control of Congress (source: Florida Election Lab).
The Democrat problem is Trump’s policies without his persona, because support for his signature positions (e.g. deporting criminal aliens, election integrity, and energy independence) polls two times higher than Trump himself (in job approval or personality). That raises the question: what if Marco Rubio and his strong Hispanic support (56%) is the Republican nominee?
It’s a good question, because the Democrats’ worst-case scenario is a leftward lurch that denies funds to law enforcement and the military, and initiates multiple impeachment trials. Divided government in America is acceptable, but loud-and-ugly extremists are not.
They Just Don’t Get It
The Democratic Party’s approval rating is currently 29% (source: NBC News). That’s 9 points below the GOP’s rating, and a reason to pivot to the middle. Not gonna happen, because Kamala Harris (CA), Wes Moore (MD), Gavin Newsom (CA), and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (NY) have all signaled their intentions to run in 2028. Get a load of this quartet’s pet positions:
- Guaranteed universal basic income
- Forgiving all medical and student debt
- Replacing all fossil fuels with subsidized renewables
- Replacing all private health insurance with Medicare for All
That list answers the “how far left” question that will be on 68% of the electorate’s minds in two years, because 35% of voters today say they’re “conservative” and another 33% say they’re “moderate” (source: Gallup). Two years in American politics is a lifetime in the press and on social media, especially when Democrat leaders promise to go “toe to toe” with the President.
That’s Chris Van Hollen speaking to his party’s far-left wing, hoping they’ll make him Senate majority leader, because they’re the future of his party and the real answer to the “how far left” question. No joke, just listen to the Democrats “new generation” describe their mid-term success (which does not come close to the party’s success under FDR: 38 governors, 333 House seats, and 75 Senate seats).
Because they so want a trifecta to enact a “new” Green New Deal, end the filibuster, abolish the Electoral College, expand the Supreme Court, and grant statehood to D.C. and Puerto Rico. Hmm… how does that lower consumer costs and add gainful jobs…or appeal to that 68% of Americans who are NOT liberal?
Good question, and one Democrats probably won’t consider.
Which is what I love about America’s liberal party.
[Note: next week’s post will prescribe the GOP remedy]
